This property is accessible via boat.
Toothaker Island lies at the south end of Mooseloomeguntic Lake. It is split in two by the Richardsontown-Rangeley Plantation line. The 210-acre easement is located on the western side in Richardsontown.
The island topography is predominantly gently sloping. On the north shore of the island, there is a combination of rocky and sandy bottom. Throughout the island there are stands of spruce-fir and other northern hardwoods.
Camping is allowed on Toothaker Island. Reservations can be made by calling Stephen Phillips Memorial Preserve Wilderness Camping at (207) 864-2003.